Reconstruction and Indecision data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3dfc7/3dfc7d2d3bd8b3c00e9bf39109a0dc4e16231130" alt=""
I never met a colleague in the teaching of a college history course who expected to learn very much from grading a batch of blue books. Yet an untidy pile of essays on my desk—essays designed to persuade me that …